Counter-Revolutionary Roman Catholicism
Log in

Dissident clergy have grown bolder under Leo while he obsesses over synodality

He has failed to rein in the most progressive elements within the Conciliar Church, most notably German Cardinal Reinhard Marx.
riaan
68
November 17, 2026
Leo and Cardinal Marx

Credit: Edgar Beltrán, The Pillar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons, and Michael Thaidigsmann, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

By now, any sane observer must admit that sitting it out, patiently waiting for things to get better, or “zipping it” has achieved absolutely nothing and that, under Leo XIV, the situation is rapidly deteriorating as progressive and leftist elements within the Conciliar Church continue to thrive.

Of course, this is not the result of a weak papacy, but instead the deliberate and focused work of a man who has received the modernist and synodal baton from his predecessors and is now running with it towards the finish line.

Whether it is the appointment of women to key positions in Vatican dicasteries, the elevation of heterodox clergy, the distortion of Catholic teaching on issues such as just war, or the alarming number of reports concerning openly pro-Masonic bishops and priests, the reality of Leo’s continuation of the Bergoglian agenda has become impossible to ignore.

Advocating for women priests

This golden age of radicalism was once again perfectly illustrated by remarks made by German Cardinal Reinhard Marx during a colloquium held at the Bavarian Catholic Academy in Munich on November 4. For the umpteenth time, this brazen subverter of Catholicism called into question the teachings, doctrines, and dogmas of the Church.

German writer Nora Bossong participated in the event. She said that she never imagined herself becoming a nun and had wanted instead to become a priest. She lamented the fact that women could not be ordained, stating that it made her feel “sad” and as though something was wrong with her.

Marx was more than sympathetic to her concerns, openly supporting her position on female ordination. “Ten years ago, no one who could even imagine the ordination of women would have been considered as a candidate for bishop. That’s over [now],” he giddily replied.

Casting doubt on Church teaching

At the meeting, Marx also recalled a discussion he had with the late Jorge Bergoglio (Francis) on the same issue. While Francis argued that the distinction between male and female vocations lay in the Petrine and Marian charisms, Marx rejected this reasoning.

“Are we really considering all the charisms that God grants us? Do we take into account all those who could preside over the Eucharist and do it well? Is it that they don’t want it halfway? I can’t accept that anymore,” said Marx.

The heterodox cardinal also expressed doubts about whether the teaching that only men can be ordained as priests had been infallibly defined. “The universal Church has a long way to go here, but in the discussion, we must already set the direction for where we’re headed,” Marx boldly said.

Vatican fails to prevent Marx’s efforts

Earlier this year, Marx encouraged clergy and pastoral ministers in the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising to use a German pastoral guide for blessing couples outside sacramental marriage, including same-sex “couples.” Although this prompted a public response from Leo, it was half-hearted. The Vatican subsequently demonstrated its tolerance, if not tacit support, by calling for dialogue on the matter with the well-heeled German Church.

Subscribe to

The Dispatch

Subscription Form [In-Post]

Finally, at the German Synodal Way’s last assembly at the beginning of the year, participants approved documents containing proposals for women’s participation in ordained ministry and ecclesiastical leadership. The documents also approved blessings for couples outside sacramental marriage, a reconsideration of Catholic teaching on homosexuality, greater lay involvement in Church governance, and discussions about married priests. But, again, the Vatican has done little beyond issuing verbal slaps on the wrist to combat this intrusion of heterodoxy.

Leo has only aided the Modernist revolution

Critics might argue that Marx is an outlier and that the German Church is an anomaly unrepresentative of the universal Church. Leo’s track record since his election tells a very different story.

Just a few months after the May 2025 conclave, Leo received the controversial pro-LGBTQ Jesuit James Martin in an audience that reportedly lasted 90 minutes. Rather than being rebuked by the newly elected pope, Martin emerged from the meeting full of praise, declaring: “I am extremely grateful and deeply consoled by my meeting with the Holy Father. He encouraged me to continue my ministry.”

Click here to support Integrity’s independent Catholic journalism!

In June 2026, one of Francis’s most liberal protégés, U.S. Cardinal Robert McElroy, scandalously presided over an “LGBTQ Mass” at an Outreach event at Georgetown University. He told attendees they should “find great hope in two important developments that have taken place during the pontificate of Pope Leo which constitute rich seeds for the unfolding of the Gospel in the years to come.”

The two “developments” he was referring to were Leo’s statement that “the unity or division of the church should not revolve around sexual matters” and a Vatican report recommending a more pastoral approach to people of faith with same-sex attractions.

No restoration of the Latin Mass

Conservatives and House Trads were also up in arms when, on two separate occasions earlier this year, Cardinal Arthur Roche explicitly stated that Leo had no intention of reversing Traditionis Custodes or returning to Summorum Pontificum.

These remarks were followed by what can only be described as an almost tyrannical crackdown in certain places on diocesan Traditional Latin Masses and at locations associated with the former Ecclesia Dei communities. Leo’s remarks aboard the papal airplane on his trip back from South America only confirm he has no intention of granting widespread use of the Tridentine Rite.

What’s more, just weeks after reports emerged that the then-auxiliary Bishop Lizardo Estrada Herrera of Cusco had participated in a Pachamama ritual, Leo elevated him to the position of coadjutor archbishop.

These examples represent only a small fraction of an overwhelming body of evidence pointing to one conclusion: under the still relatively short reign of Leo XIV, leftist, liberal, and progressive elements within the Conciliar Church are not merely tolerated but actively encouraged and, more often than not, rewarded for their heterodoxy.

This stands in stark contrast to the silencing, excommunication, and marginalization of not only those who seek to practice the traditional Catholic faith, but in many cases even of moderate conservatives.  

In Category
riaan

Riaan Van Zyl is a convert to the faith, an ultra-Traditionalist Catholic Counter-Revolutionary, and advocate for integralism. A seasoned journalist, he has worked as a crime and political reporter, investigative writer, and columnist. His Catholic writing has thus far appeared on his blog, Radical Fidelity. He occasionally commits poetry and lives in Roodepoort, South Africa

68

Stephen Kokx is co-founder and editor-in-chief of Integrity Magazine. A former community college instructor, he has written and spoken extensively about Catholic social teaching, politics, and spirituality. He previously worked for the Archdiocese of Chicago and LifeSiteNews. His essays have appeared on a variety of Catholic media outlets, including his Kokx News Substack. He is the author of two books, Navigating the Crisis in the Church: Essays in Defense of Traditional Catholicism and St. Alphonsus for the 21st Century: A Handbook for Holiness. His forthcoming What Your Priest Isn't Telling You About Vatican II is due out later this year.

Join the Conversation

Become an exclusive Integrity member to comment on articles.

Make a donation with Donorbox. Then, log in with your Integrity account.

Related posts