Counter-Revolutionary Roman Catholicism
Log in

Leo pushes Synodality in Chiclayo as abuse controversy looms over trip

José Enrique Escardó claims he was excluded from a meeting Leo held with victims while in Peru.
riaan
November 16, 2026
Leo XIV at a microphone speaking.

Credit: MS Now, YouTube

On Nov. 13-14, as part of his apostolic journey to Uruguay, Argentina and Peru, Leo XIV returned to the Diocese of Chiclayo, where he was bishop from 2015 to 2023, before Francis appointed him prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops.

Leo’s return was celebrated by thousands of people who filled the streets and venues where he appeared, with some even chanting, “El Papa es Chiclayano!” (“The Pope is from Chiclayo!”).

But, as usual, Leo’s addresses and homilies during his visit were used, sometimes subtly and sometimes quite overtly, to promote and consolidate the new religion he inherited from his predecessors.

At his first stop near the Pampas de Pimentel, Leo told the crowd that “love of neighbor is at the heart of the Christian message” and that “this practical, committed and respectful love also demonstrates the unbreakable bond between the proclamation of the Gospel and the effort to transform the structures of human coexistence.”

Especially noteworthy was Leo’s next address, a homily at the Shrine of Our Lady of Peace in the diocese. Capitalizing on the ecstatic adulation of the Chiclayano faithful, Leo used the speech to reiterate the synodal ideology in language accessible to ordinary Catholics.

Invoking his predecessor and mentor, he told the congregation that “one integral dimension of the Church, promoted with great enthusiasm by Pope Francis, is synodality, which means walking together, listening, discerning and participating as co-responsible members in the mission.”

He then returned to his obsession with human dignity and UN secularism. “Listening to social and cultural realities; defending human dignity; accompanying families, young people, migrants, indigenous peoples and those living in poverty; and working for justice, peace and the common good are not optional tasks, they are requirements of our ecclesial mission,” he said.

Leo further laid out the nuts and bolts of synodal practice, describing it as requiring “a spirituality founded on prayer, listening to the word, participation in the Holy Mass, Eucharistic Adoration, fraternal dialogue and communal discernment.”

Subscribe to

The Dispatch

Subscription Form [In-Post]

He concluded his mini-catechesis with a call to revitalize parish councils, arguing that they are well placed “to adopt this synodal style of communion, participation and mission” and to help “the community to listen, understand reality, discern priorities and formulate more appropriate responses”.

But his visit was not all rock-star crowds and hero worship. An old skeleton in his Chiclayo closet had begun rattling its bones once again.

Media reports earlier this year exposed several controversies dating back to Leo’s time as bishop of the Peruvian diocese. The two most notable concerned his participation in a pagan Pachamama ritual and his handling of an abuse case involving an old friend named Fr. Eleuterio Vásquez González — widely known as “Father Lute.”

Click here to support Integrity’s independent reporting!

A week before Leo’s visit to Chiclayo, where he was also scheduled to meet with abuse victims, José Enrique Escardó, the first public accuser of the Sodalitium of Christian Life and president of the Network of Survivors Peru, publicly claimed that he had been excluded from a meeting Leo was to hold with victims while in Peru.

Escardó further alleged that the apostolic nuncio in Peru, Paolo Rocco Gualtieri, and the president of the Peruvian Episcopal Conference, Carlos García Camader, were “terrified” of what he might have revealed at the meeting.

According to Escardó, there had been a “filtering” of the victims selected to meet with Leo “so that the ‘uncomfortable’ ones for the Church do not enter and only those who do not make noise in networks and media are there.”

These allegations inevitably raise questions about whether the meeting with victims was carefully managed to shield Leo, who is now returning to Rome, and other prelates who may have been involved in, or connected to, the scandal.

In Category
riaan

Riaan Van Zyl is a convert to the faith, an ultra-Traditionalist Catholic Counter-Revolutionary, and advocate for integralism. A seasoned journalist, he has worked as a crime and political reporter, investigative writer, and columnist. His Catholic writing has thus far appeared on his blog, Radical Fidelity. He occasionally commits poetry and lives in Roodepoort, South Africa

Join the Conversation

Become an exclusive Integrity member to comment on articles.

Make a donation with Donorbox. Then, log in with your Integrity account.

Related posts